Baby Carrier Review: wrap, front/backpack, sling

Considering I bought my third baby carrier today (and many moms don’t even have one), I figure I could do a review on the different types. Now, I won’t wear my baby 24/7, but there are great benefits to “wearing” your baby (especially skin-to-skin contact, known as kangaroo care). For example, wearing Champ lets me hold him, which reduces crying and helps him sleep, but also lets me be hands free, so I can actually get things done.

Anyway, I have three carriers: a wrap (Moby), a front/backpack carrier (Infantino EcoSash), and a homemade ring sling. There are other brands of wraps, front/backpacks, and ring slings. We didn’t get a Baby Bjorn, one of the highest rated and most common baby carriers, because it was too metro and European for my husband. But if you are looking for a common, solid carrier (or just one with straps and buckles), a Bjorn is highly recommended. By people who have actually used them.

Wrap Style (Moby Wrap)

Price:  Moby Wrap: $40-70. Other Wrap Carriers: $5 (make your own)–$200

Ease of use:  The wrap takes a few minutes to figure out, and there are different ways to wrap it. But once you get the hang of it (which doesn’t take long, esp. if you are watching how-to vids on YouTube), it is fairly easy.

Comfort:  This is a very comfortable carrier. The weight of the baby is spread out evenly. I felt no back or shoulder pain wearing Champ. It was basically like I was pregnant again when I was holding him in the front, in his first few weeks.

Fool-proof:  Once you figure out how to put it on, the wrap is pretty easy to get right. The biggest problem comes from twisted fabric. There are really helpful instructions that come with the Moby Wrap. If you make your own wrap, there are plenty of instructions online.

Design:  The Moby Wrap has the biggest variety in design that I have seen. A large variety of different colors and designs, including seasonal choices.

Will Dad wear it? Mine? Never. But some men will wear them.

Time it takes to put on:  The wrap definitely takes the longest, but even that isn’t much time…about 45 seconds to put on and 30-45 seconds to get the baby in.

Versatility:  The Moby Wrap is for babies and toddlers 8-35 lbs. These positions are the ones listed in the expanded Moby Instruction Booklet (here’s the PDF). I’ll bet there are even more to be found online.


0-3 months (newborn–3 mo)—Newborn hug hold, Kangaroo hold, Cradle/ Nursing hold, twin hug hold, twin cradle hold

3-6 months(3–6 mo infants)—Hug hold, Kangaroo hold, Cradle/ Nursing hold, Lotus hold, Joey Hold, twin hug hold, twin cradle hold

6+ mo(6+ mo infants)— Kangaroo hold, Cradle/ Nursing hold, Lotus Hold, Joey Hold, hip hold, hike (back) hold

toddler (Toddlers)—Joey Hold, Hip Hold, Hike (back) hold

Front/Backpack Style (Infantino Ecosash)

Price:  Infantino Ecosash: $60. Infantino Flip: $30. Other Similar Carriers: $15–$230

Ease of use:  Not only are the instructions very easy to understand and carry out, but the instructions are also printed on the carrier, stitched onto the straps.

Comfort:  Again, a very comfortable carrier. Champ loves being vertical, too. Sometimes his legs get a bit awkward in the carrier, however, but he usually doesn’t mind, and he is easy to adjust.

Fool-proof: It’s pretty hard to mess this up. Just make sure you tie the waist band around your natural waist. Too low, and it will be uncomfortable (same goes for any carrier).

Design:  I really like the design. I like the cute pattern on the front and the black color. The fact that it ties makes it extremely easy to adjust (much more than something with buckles or straps you have to loosen and tighten), especially if more than one person will be using the carrier. The front design pattern is also reversible, to a solid black.

Will Dad wear it? Out of our carriers, LT is most likely to wear this one. But the design will be switched to all black. For a more “masculine” option, go for something with straps rather than ties. I recommend the Infantino Flip Carrier, which we were planning on getting, but was out of stock.

Time it takes to put on:  I’ll time how long it takes to get on and how long it takes to get the baby in. Because this ties, it is faster to get fitted than a buckle / adjustable strap carrier.

Versatility:  The Infantino Ecosash is for babies and toddlers 8-35 lbs. It “only” offers three positions—front facing in, front facing out, and backpack—not particularly comparable to a wrap or sling. But, considering many baby carriers only offer one or two positions, this is still an improvement.


0-3 months (newborn–3 mo)—front facing in

3-6 months(3–6 mo infants)—front facing in, front facing out

6+ mo(6+ mo infants)— front facing in, front facing out, backpack(?)

toddler (Toddlers)— front facing in, front facing out, backpack

Sling Style (homemade)

Price:  My handmade (albeit purchased) carrier: $6 Other Similar Slings: $12–$300 (yeah. Some are made from silk. But I wouldn’t pay $300 for a sling even if it were made by silkworms who could speak Latin and dance the Sardana.)

Ease of use:  EXTREMELY straightforward when it comes to putting it on. If you have ever worn a belt with D-rings, you can wear a sling. Positioning the baby correctly was something I am still getting used to, though. Perhaps because he is so squirmy, or because I had it on wrong…

Comfort:  If you wear this too low or don’t put it on your shoulder (wearing it on your neck), it is very uncomfortable. These are pretty easy fixes, but even wearing it correctly can give you some back and shoulder strain, since it is an asymmetrical carrier. Be sure to switch sides often.

Fool-proof: It’s very easy to put on, but you will likely need instructions to figure out how to put the baby in the different holds.

Design:  This looks more fashionable than the other carriers, because you have an endless choice of fabrics, and some of them look more like a baby-carrying accessory than an uber-obvious baby carrier.

Will Dad wear it? Doubtful, unless he doesn’t mind also wearing purses, decorative scarves, or ascots.

Time it takes to put on:  To put on the sling, you just throw it over your head. Maybe 2-5 seconds to get that sucker on. Getting the baby in might take 10-30 seconds, depending on position.

Versatility:  A popular ring sling brand is the Maya Sling. They are recommended for 8-35 lbs. Slings have more versatility than fitted, formed carriers. However, they don’t have quite as much versatility as a wrap carrier, the main difference being the front-facing and twin holds (you need two ring slings for twins).


0-3 months (newborn–3 mo)—tummy to tummy, cradle

3-6 months(3–6 mo infants)—tummy to tummy, cradle

6+ mo(6+ mo infants)— tummy to tummy, cradle, hip carry, back carry

toddler (Toddlers)— hip carry, back carry

For more information on baby carriers, checkout the Sling Station

Well, that wraps it up (bahaha. Sorry. Ahem.) I will post some photos of myself carrying my little Champ in our 3 carriers once I wash the spit up off of them…


2 thoughts on “Baby Carrier Review: wrap, front/backpack, sling

  1. Love it!!

    Just found your blog…

    I have my own of course but I just found out that I am expecting…

    8weeks :)

    Slowly beginning to wonder what will happen in the coming months!

    Your bub is adorable and I personally adore wraps – obviously have never worn one but they just look so cosy and comfortable!

    Hope all is well for you, Daddy and Joey!

This is the comment fountain! Drop your two cents here.

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s